Sunday, January 1, 2012

Sinhalese, Tamils and Elephants

These are some overall reflections about Sri Lanka after 2 weeks of travel and a bit of reading. Some of my "facts" may not be totally accurate, but nevertheless I thought I would share my impressions. I hope you can bear with me on this long and convoluted blog post.

The national religion of Sri Lanka is Buddhism. For the most part, all of the Buddhists are ethnic Sinhalese people. The Sinhalese apparently came to Sri Lanka about 3000 years ago and have an established history of Sinhalese kings dating back for well over 2000 years. They speak Sinhala, a language that exists essentially nowhere else. There is a tooth relic, purported to have been the Buddha's tooth, which has been both a religious icon and a national treasure for over 2 millennia. Historically, the tooth relic would always be kept in the capitol, and was an accepted symbol of the king's right to the throne. Several times, invading armies and colonizers thought they had destroyed the tooth relic, but always the tooth relic would reappear. On Christmas day, we visited the Temple of the Tooth in Kandy, arriving at 6 am so we could enter with masses of Buddhist devotees bearing gifts of lotus flowers to file past an open doorway allowing a glimpse from about 50 feet away of the ornate vessel which holds the tooth relic.

While virtually all of the Buddhists are Sinhalese, not all of the ethnic Sinhalese are Buddhists. A fair number converted to catholicism in the 17th, 18th, and 19th centuries during colonial rule (first by the Portuguese, then the Dutch, then the British). Buddhists remain a large majority in the country, and the Sinhalese are even a larger majority.

The minority Tamil population are predominantly Hindu (some of them also converted to Catholicism during the colonial years). They originate from India,but are believed to possibly have been on the island even earlier than the Sinhalese, apparently dating back to when the Indian Ocean flooded the land bridge connecting Sri Lanka to India. They speak Tamil. These "Sri Lankan Tamils" mostly settled in the north and east of the island. Since the arrival of the Sinhalese they have always been a minority, but were apparently well accepted during the many centuries of Sinhalese kings. Most ancient Buddhist temples are adorned with some Hindu images around the entrance, and there are Hindu temples near the royal palaces at ancient ruin sites. Hindu Tamils were at times close advisers and protectors of Sinhalese kings, but it was apparently accepted that they would never be rulers themselves.

There are also the "Indian Tamils". This is a population in the south central hill country of the nation who were brought in by the British from southern India to harvest the tea. They are a small minority nationwide, but actually constitute a local majority in some areas of tea plantations.

The island is also populated by elephants. The numbers have dwindled, with a currently disputed estimate of 7800 remaining. Suffice it to say that there used to be many more. They are primarily threatened by development, but also captured for religious purposes, and exploited for economic benefit.

My stereotypic impression of Buddhism has always been of a meditative religion, focused on enlightenment, disavowing the material world; an image of peace and harmony. It has therefore been difficult for me to incorporate what I have learned about this Buddhist culture's current relationship to the minority Tamil population, and the dwindling population of elephants. Then again, I should really not be surprised, because similar paradoxes seem to often arise when a religion is merged with government power.

During the conversion from British colonial rule to independence in the first half of the 20th century, the British established a native Sri Lankan subordinate governing body with essentially equal Sinhalese and Tamil representation. Shortly after independence in 1948, a populist movement arose to shift from ethnic representation in government to a democracy. This shifted political power to the Sinhalese. From the Sinhalese perspective, this was justifiable based on their majority status, and the historical precedent that in the pre-colonial era the island had always been ruled by Sinhalese. They cited the need to protect Sinhalese culture and language which exist nowhere else in the world. There was also a darker undercurrent of resentment against the Tamils who had received a disproportionate amount of education compared to the Sinhalese, and thus often better jobs. At one point, a Buddhist monk assassinated a president who did not believe strongly enough in the need for Sinhalese and Buddhist superiority.

The resentment exploded into brutal ethnic violence at times, with Sinhalese beating and raping ethnic Tamils. There were also government rules restricting Tamil education and advancement. These conditions eventually led to the Tamil separatist movement which sought an independent Tamil nation in the heavily Tamil north and east of the island. When political efforts for independence failed, the LTTE (Tamil Tigers) began their prolonged violent civil war in 1983. They were eventually brutally defeated by the government in 2009 after several years of advanced technological satellite intelligence assistance from the US military.

There is now a somewhat tentative peace, but it seems quite uncertain if it will hold. During our travels almost all of the Sri Lankans we met were Sinhalese (mostly Buddhist, some Catholic). The largest Tamil city of Jaffna in the north has not yet been declared safe for tourism. (This city bore the brunt of the war, and I read in a medical journal about the extraordinarily high rate of PTSD there.) We did venture to the beautiful beach area of Trincomalee where the majority are Tamil. We noticed more Hindu garb, more Hindu temples, more Hindu decorations, and absolutely no evidence of any conflict in our very limited exposure there.

The Sinhalese who spoke to me about the conflict invariably expressed concern that it may not be over, and they seemed very dubious about the possibility of a long term solution.

For some reason, probably more emotional than logical, I see the elephant situation as analogous. Before coming to Sri Lanka I never would have dreamed that capturing elephants would be associated with the quest for enlightenment. Yet here it is. As depicted in ancient texts and paintings, the tooth relic was transported by an elephant. To commemorate this glorious event, many of the Buddhist temples require an elephant to march in their ceremonial parades. Ideally this must be a male elephant with tusks; there are also several other ideal anatomical attributes. There is a small museum at the Temple of the Tooth in Kandy devoted to Sri Dalaga, the glorious "tusker" who bore the tooth relic in the annual Perahera ceremonial parade for most of the 20th century.

It is now extremely rare to find a tusked elephant in the wild. This of course is not the only reason (or perhaps even the major reason) elephants are endangered. Development encroaches on their habitat. Elephants are killed when they encroach back into human populated areas. It is a complex problem.

We were fortunate to see many elephants in the vicinity of Habarana, where we were staying the last 4 days of our trip. The first of those days (26 December, the 7th anniversary of the Boxing Day tsunami in 2004) we went on a jeep safari in the new "Eco-park". For over an hour we traveled on incredibly rutted and flooded dirt roadways through the scrubby jungle. At one point our impressively skilled driver disembarked to extricate another jeep from a deep muddy rut. Our guide stood in the back of the jeep with us, pointing out birds and interesting fauna. As the number of birds he pointed out increased, our hopes of seeing elephants started to fade. But then he pointed to an elephant on a hillside a couple hundred yards away. Within minutes our driver had us maneuvered within about 50 feet to take pictures. There were 6 elephants, and within minutes about a dozen jeeps with tourists.

We subsequently got a decent view of 2 other elephants before the jeep exited the jungle back onto the paved road several miles from where we started. On the drive back down the road, there were several vehicles pulled over. About 50 yards off the road there was a herd of about 12 elephants grazing. Our driver maneuvered us into position and we just watched in wonder and took pictures for about 30 minutes as the sun was setting.

Two days later (28 December) we took our day trip to the beach at Trincomalee. On the way home at night, in a similar area just a few miles from our hotel, Sarath suddenly pulled the van to the side of the road. We were just a few feet away from a family of elephants.

We had 3 additional sightings of elephants by the side of the rode. On one of those occasions just Lee and I were in the van (we had stupidly forgotten our expensive archeological site admission tickets for Polonnaruwa and had to return to the hotel). We saw the elephant on the way back to the hotel, and again on the way back to the ruins. We later learned from Sarath (who learned it from a tour bus driver) that shortly after we took our pictures, a tuk-tuk with tourists stopped to do the same. Apparently the people were out of the tuk-tuk when the elephant knocked it over and deftly removed their food from the vehicle.

There are elephant rides available for tourists in this area. I have to admit that I was intrigued by the idea of sitting atop one of these majestic beasts and wading across rivers as deep as the elephant's shoulders. But after seeing them in the wild, I really couldn't bear to economically encourage this exploitation.

And is the Buddhist parading of elephants an exploitation? I suppose. But it is also a veneration of the elephant, and all the Buddhists I spoke to seemed to have great respect for the need to protect wildlife elephant habitat. And who am I, to be critical of an indigenous people that has successfully existed and maintained its culture on an island for thousands of years? Despite centuries of colonial exploitation and the current explosion of western culture, these people continue to have a strong bond to the history exemplified in their extraordinary archeological ruins. I will hopefully find time to post about our visits to the fabulous archeological sites.

No comments:

Post a Comment